Merkel may win election, but lose her finance minister

Schaeuble gives a speech for a budget debate at the German national Parliament in Berlin.

SASBACHWALDEN, Germany: Wolfgang Schaeuble has won his parliamentary seat a dozen times, survived an attempt on his life and guided Angela Merkel through the eurozone crisis. Now, the German chancellor may have to sacrifice him to secure a coalition deal. Merkel’s conservatives are likely to win a national election on Sept. 24, but lack of an overall majority could force them to continue their alliance with the center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD).

SPD leaders say their price for a rerun of the current “grand coalition” would be for Schaeuble to vacate the Finance Ministry and hand it to them.

Schaeuble personifies the fiscal discipline and financial stability that many Germans crave. But for the SPD he goes too far.

For Merkel’s political opponents, Schaeuble’s emphasis that both Germany and other EU countries adhere to Europe’s budget rules risks denying French President Emmanuel Macron the flexibility to revive his country’s economy.

Germany is awash with tax revenues but France is in a tighter spot. The SPD worries that insistence on French budget discipline will not give Macron the room for maneuver to foster growth. If Macron fails, the SPD’s concern is the EU will fail or that far-right leader Marine Le Pen could win power.

SPD Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel said he had asked Merkel which scenario would be more expensive for Germany: a slightly higher budget deficit in France or Le Pen as president in five years.

“We Germans must change our position,” Gabriel said.

Softening Schaeuble’s approach to the eurozone would not go down well with many Germans. In his home region of Baden-Wuerttemberg, where hard work and saving is a way of life, he enjoys cult status.

In Schaeuble’s view, governments must stop piling up debt so that future policymakers still have some money to spend.

In a wheelchair since a deranged man shot him at an election campaign event a few days after German reunification in 1990, Schaeuble lives for the job and has signaled his willingness to stay in politics.

“I’m ready to continue,” he told voters in Sasbachwalden, his home town near the French border.

In May, he flew half way around the world to spend 12 hours in Durban, where he attended several panels at the World Economic Forum on Africa, backed efforts to attract more investment and lectured students on how the EU works.

It is this relentless drive that commands the respect of voters and colleagues alike.

“When I go to breakfasts and party meetings with him, he is the one who is the most aggressive – ready to take on the Social Democrats,” a senior German government official said.

But while polls suggest Merkel will win a fourth term in September, she might end up losing Schaeuble as finance minister. Merkel faces tricky coalition talks over ministerial jobs in the next Parliament.

Senior members of the two parties most likely to be her junior coalition partner – the SPD and the business-friendly Free Democrats (FDP) – have made clear that they have their eye on the Finance Ministry this time.

“The SPD won’t repeat the mistake it made during the coalition talks four years ago,” Gabriel said.

In 2013, the SPD focused mainly on domestic issues and pushed for the introduction of a national minimum wage. It consequently got the Labor Ministry, among other departments such as economic affairs and foreign relations.

Now, the SPD’s candidate for chancellor, Martin Schulz, has made investment and solidarity with Europe a cornerstone of his campaign, signaling a less rigid stance on the budget.

If the Social Democrats are forced into yet another grand coalition under Merkel, it would be “very important” for the SPD to get the Finance Ministry, a senior SPD source told Reuters.

“If there’s one thing we Social Democrats have learned, it’s this: We should not enter coalition again without controlling the Finance Ministry,” SPD budget lawmaker Johannes Kahrs told Reuters.

The smaller FDP shares similar thoughts. A senior FDP source said the party was interested in the Finance Ministry, although it could be more difficult for it to achieve this.

Senior members of Merkel’s CDU/CSU conservative bloc acknowledge that she could win the election and still be forced to give up Schaeuble as finance minister.

Eckhardt Rehberg, Merkel’s chief budget lawmaker in Parliament, said his party would find it hard to keep the Finance Ministry if the election produced another “grand coalition” with the SPD – an option both parties have said they dislike.

“Keeping the Finance Ministry will be most difficult to achieve with the SPD as junior partner because the party has put a strong emphasis on finances and Europe,” Rehberg told Reuters.

“If we have a similar situation on election night as we did four years ago, the SPD is likely to demand not ‘only’ the Finance Ministry but ‘also’ the Finance Ministry,” he added.

It remains unclear whether Merkel will have to sacrifice Schaeuble. But his departure would be a blow for the chancellor’s goal of strengthening integration within the EU once Britain leaves, or at least within the eurozone.

For Merkel, deeper integration is a question of sequencing.

This is where Schaeuble could help her: keeping skeptical German voters and lawmakers on board by insisting France and the southern eurozone countries reform first, before agreeing to bind Germany’s economic fate closer to theirs.

“If France becomes stronger that would help,” one senior official close to Merkel said.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on July 22, 2017, on page 6.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here