For Britain’s Cameron, a gamble too far

LONDON: Until last month, the advice David Cameron chose to give fellow British parliamentarians on his last day as prime minister Wednesday might have seemed apt. “Nothing is really impossible if you put your mind to it,” said the man who had rescued his Conservative Party from the political wilderness, won two elections and successfully gambled that Scots would stay in the United Kingdom if given the choice.

It sounded strangely off-key, however, given the circumstances of his own downfall – the outcome of a failed gamble that Britons, given the choice, would choose to stay in the European Union.

The June 23 referendum vote for “Brexit” not only made Cameron’s own position untenable but left both Britain and the EU facing years of uncertainty as they try to forge new rules on trade, investment, migration and a string of other key areas.

It was not supposed to end like this for Britain’s youngest prime minister in nearly two centuries, who navigated five years of coalition politics to win a narrow majority in 2015 on a platform of economic recovery and social reform.

The obstacle he found impossible to surmount was the long-running Euroskepticism within his own party, which, along with a perceived threat from the new, anti-EU UKIP party, persuaded him to try to lay the issue to rest by calling a plebiscite.

“I think it’s right when you’re trying to settle a really big constitutional issue, you don’t just rely on parliament, you ask the people as well,” Cameron told Parliament when asked, tauntingly, if he had succeeded on the issue of Europe.

“We made a promise, and we kept a promise.”

Voters ignored Cameron’s warnings that going it alone would be a “leap in the dark” that would bring on a self-inflicted recession and Cameron himself underestimated public anger at the establishment, exacerbated by his government’s spending cuts.

Steven Fielding, politics professor at Nottingham University, said the prime minister could have told his party a referendum would done too much economic harm.

“For the effect that it will undoubtedly have on Britain, and for the fact the British people decided to take the decision that was the very opposite to the one he was personally recommending, he will go down as a complete failure in terms of the direction he wanted to take Britain in.”

Considering the reasons for Cameron’s downfall, his former Oxford University politics tutor Vernon Bogdanor pointed to the “huge popular eruption” of anger reflected in the referendum, and the widening of the gap between politicians and the people.

“Although his heart was in the right place about dealing with those problems, the gap certainly, I think, increased under his premiership,” said Bogdanor, now research professor at King’s College London.

Some commentators have compared Cameron’s departure to the ignominious exit of premier Anthony Eden after Britain and France’s failed military attempt to recapture control of the Suez Canal from Egypt in 1956. Bogdanor disagrees.

“Eden was defined by Suez because he wasn’t prime minister for very long. I don’t think Cameron will be defined just by Europe.”

Answering questions from MPs for the final time as prime minister, Cameron trumpeted his economic record: 2.5 million more people in work, millions of apprenticeships, a growth rate among the highest in the developed world.

Under his Finance Minister George Osborne, the budget deficit narrowed from more than 10 percent of gross domestic product to less than 4 percent, although that came at the price of deep and painful cuts to public spending.

Cameron overcame three successive election defeats for his Conservative Party by changing its image from that of a party of the wealthy and old to one more in touch with modern life. He legalized gay marriage and hauled the economy out of deep recession after the global financial crisis.

But his calls for a “Big Society” and austerity mantra of “We’re all in this together” rang hollow for many Britons, distrustful of his wealthy background and education at Eton College, an elite boarding school west of London.

On the world stage, Cameron committed British military support for the Libyan opposition that overthrew autocrat Moammar Gadhafi in 2011, a decision he defended despite the years of chaos that ensued. He suffered a humiliating and unexpected defeat in 2013 when Parliament voted to reject military action against Syrian President Bashar Assad.

At home, in an earlier referendum gamble, he gave Scots the opportunity to vote on independence in 2014, and indiscreetly revealed that Queen Elizabeth had “purred” with pleasure when told they had chosen to stay in the United Kingdom.

But the independence question has resurfaced in the wake of the Brexit vote, in which Scots favored remaining in the EU, a second major issue that he has failed to lay to rest.

In Parliament on his last day, Cameron tried to address the public disconnect with the political class by praising MPs for their diligence as public servants. But he mainly kept things light, projecting the breezy confidence that contrasted with his tortured predecessor, former Labour leader Gordon Brown.

“I was the future once,” Cameron said. “Other than one meeting this afternoon with Her Majesty the Queen, the diary for the rest of my day is remarkably light.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on July 14, 2016, on page 6.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here